Penang Amanah has urged the state government to review policies allowing pets, particularly dogs, into enclosed shopping malls following public complaints over discomfort and religious sensitivities.
Fadzlee Daie, from the party’s Syariah and Dakwah bureau, said the call comes in response to a viral social media post describing a Muslim visitor’s unpleasant experience at a shopping mall in Penang, where dogs were reportedly allowed on certain days.
“The visitor said they were shocked and uncomfortable after encountering a dog in a lift and on shopping floors, unaware the mall practised a ‘pet-friendly’ policy,” Fadzlee said.
While respecting private mall operators’ rights to set business policies, he stressed that such decisions should take into account Penang’s demographic, cultural, and religious context. “Shopping malls are no longer just commercial spaces but shared areas frequented by families, senior citizens, tourists, and Muslim consumers,” he added.
Fadzlee highlighted that, from an Islamic perspective, dogs are considered “najis mughallazah” (severe impurity), and contact requires a specific cleansing process. Given that most Malaysian Muslims follow the Syafie school of thought, he said dogs in enclosed spaces such as lifts, narrow walkways, and dining areas raise legitimate concerns about cleanliness and religious observance.
He emphasised that discomfort among Muslims in such situations should not be dismissed as intolerance, but understood within the context of religious obligations. Beyond religion, Fadzlee noted public safety and health concerns, including phobias, allergies, past trauma, and the potential for unpredictable animal behaviour in crowded mall environments.
Fadzlee also criticised what he described as inadequate public communication, noting that clear and visible notices were lacking and online announcements alone were insufficient, particularly for tourists and elderly visitors.
He urged the state government and local authorities to reassess existing guidelines, consult religious authorities, conduct social impact assessments, and ensure clear public notification for any special policies. He also proposed alternative approaches, such as restricting pet-friendly activities to outdoor areas or designated events, to maintain social harmony.
The New Straits Times has reached out to state Local Government Committee chairman H’ng Mooi Lye and Penang Island City Council mayor Datuk A. Rajendran for comments and is awaiting their response.
