A 54-year-old man who lured a British woman thousands of miles from home after grooming her on a fetish website has been found guilty of kidnapping and murdering her in the United States.
Dwain Hall was convicted of kidnapping and first-degree murder following a trial in Ocala, Florida, on Friday. He was subsequently sentenced to life in prison.
Hall had persuaded 32-year-old Sonia Exelby, from Southsea, Hampshire, to travel to the US before stabbing her to death and burying her body in Marion County.
Her remains were discovered on October 17, 2025, five days after she was reported missing from her home.
During the trial, prosecutors revealed that Hall, who used the online username Alpha Sadist, had groomed Exelby through a now-defunct website and manipulated her for years. He had also demanded US$4,000 (£3,000) for him to kill her.
Assistant state attorney Amy Berndt told the court that Hall had targeted Exelby because of her mental health struggles and exploited her vulnerabilities for his own gratification.
“He targeted her because of her mental illness and he exploited her for his own sadistic pleasure,” she said.
Berndt added that Hall killed Exelby after getting her alone, far away from home and unable to make rational decisions. She described him as her “executioner”, telling jurors that Exelby had been searching for someone willing to end her life.
Hall remained impassive as the jury delivered its unanimous guilty verdict.
Exelby’s sister, Gemma Isaj, said the family would never be the same following the tragedy, describing her sibling as a vulnerable person who had been preyed upon and a “beautiful soul” who had been taken.
She also said Exelby had believed she could prevent others from being harmed and that the verdict had delivered justice. Isaj added that the family would continue raising awareness about mental health in her name and draw attention to the dangers of websites such as Motherless.com.
Her brother, Barry Wilton, accused Hall of pretending to care for Exelby while exploiting her vulnerabilities to fulfil his “sick fantasies”.
He said Hall had the opportunity to save her but instead took her away from the family.
Exelby was reported missing on October 12, 2025, by which time police had established that she had left the country. Investigators later traced Hall through an attempted use of her bank card by a roadside assistance company owned by him.
The jury was also told that Exelby’s consent could not serve as a defence to first-degree murder. The court heard that consent must be intelligent, knowing and voluntary, and does not include submission obtained through exploitation, threats of force or intimidation.

